That's a question for an attorney, which I am not.  However, if someone is injured or suffers a loss as a result of your private road, we can safely assume that a plaintiff's attorney would go after anyone concerned: The owner(s) of the parcel(s) of land the road passes through, the road association which maintains the road, and the individual members of the association.  
  
  In other words, I think you'd all be at risk.